My Cat Doesn't React to Catnip: What to Try Instead

Around one in three cats doesn't react to catnip. Here's why, and the natural alternatives worth trying.

6 min read
Matatabi silver vine sticks wrapped in jute for cats
Contents ▾

    Short answer: if your cat doesn't react to catnip, nothing is wrong. Around one in three adult cats simply isn't sensitive to it, and kittens usually don't react until they're a few months old. The good news is that many of those cats do react to matatabi (silver vine) or valerian instead. And every cat, scent-lover or not, responds to a toy that moves like prey.

    I'm Amy, and I make natural cat toys in my studio in Wuppertal. Of our two cats, one goes wild for catnip and the other gives it a polite sniff and walks off. So this question comes up in our house too.

    Key takeaways

    • Around one in three adult cats doesn't react to catnip. It's inherited and completely normal.
    • Most kittens don't react until around 3 to 6 months old.
    • Try matatabi (silver vine): in one study about 8 in 10 cats reacted to it, including many that ignored catnip.
    • Valerian is another option, especially in kicker toys.
    • Every cat responds to a toy that moves like prey, scent or no scent.

    Why some cats don't react to catnip

    Catnip's effect comes from a natural compound called nepetalactone. Whether a cat responds to it is largely inherited, so some cats just don't have the sensitivity. It isn't a sign of illness, stress or a "boring" cat.

    Age matters too. Most kittens show little or no interest until somewhere around three to six months. Some older cats also become less interested over time.

    A 2017 study of 100 cats found that about two in three reacted to catnip, while around eight in ten reacted to silver vine and roughly half reacted to valerian. Many of the cats that ignored catnip responded to one of the others. That's why it's worth trying more than one. For the full comparison, read what does catnip do to cats? Catnip vs matatabi vs valerian.

    Quick checks before you give up

    • Is the catnip fresh? Dried catnip loses its scent over time, especially if it's stored open. Old toys may simply have run out. Try fresh dried catnip and crush a little between your fingers to release the oils.
    • Is it the right moment? A cat that's sleepy, just eaten or feeling unsettled may ignore it. Offer it when they're relaxed and curious.
    • Too much at once? Some cats find a strong smell off-putting. A small pinch is plenty.
    • Is your cat still a kitten? Wait a few months and try again. In the meantime, choose herb-free kitten toys.
    Old catnip?Toys lose their scent over time. Before you give up, read how to refresh catnip toys.

    Try matatabi (silver vine)

    Matatabi, also called silver vine, is a climbing plant from East Asia. Its dried sticks and fruit galls contain different compounds from catnip, and many cats find them irresistible. Cats usually chew, lick and rub their cheeks on the sticks, which also gives their teeth a gentle workout.

    Supervise chewing and replace sticks once they splinter or get very short.

    Matatabi silver vine sticks wrapped in jute for cats
    Jute-wrapped matatabi sticks for cats who like to chew and grab.

    Try silver vine
    Natural matatabi chew sticks, a great first try for cats that ignore catnip.

    Shop matatabi

    Try valerian

    Valerian root has a strong, earthy smell that people often don't love, but some cats do. It tends to suit cats who like to grab, hug and kick. A kicker filled with valerian is a good way to try it.

    Valerian and herb-free versions of our toys are made to order, so allow up to 5 working days before dispatch.

    Refillable kicker toy with a removable catnip pouch
    The refillable kicker: swap between catnip and valerian to test what your cat prefers.

    Toys that work without any scent

    Scent is a bonus, not the main event. What every cat is wired for is the hunt: watching, stalking, pouncing and catching. A toy that moves like prey works for all cats, including ones that ignore every herb.

    Two short sessions of ten minutes a day make a real difference, especially for indoor cats. Why play matters so much for cats.

    How to test what your cat likes

    1. Offer one scent at a time, a day or two apart, so you can tell what's working.
    2. Put it on the floor near your cat rather than in their face, and let them come to it.
    3. Watch for sniffing, licking, chewing, rolling, rubbing their cheeks or kicking. Even a calm, happy lie-down next to the toy counts.
    4. Give it a few minutes, then put it away. Scented toys stay more exciting if they aren't out all the time.

    If you'd rather not guess, a mixed gift set includes catnip, matatabi and plain wool toys in one box, so you can see what your cat picks. You can also read our guide to choosing a toy by play style.

    A safety note: catnip, matatabi and valerian are considered safe for cats in normal amounts. Supervise play, especially with chew sticks and wands, and remove any toy that's damaged. If your cat has a health condition, check with your vet first.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is it normal for a cat not to react to catnip?

    Yes. Around one in three cats doesn't react, and the trait is largely inherited. Kittens usually don't react until they're a few months old.

    What is the best catnip alternative?

    Matatabi (silver vine) is the most popular alternative, and many cats that ignore catnip react to it. Valerian is another option, especially in kicker toys.

    Can old catnip stop working?

    Yes. Dried catnip slowly loses its scent. Refresh toys with fresh catnip and store it in an airtight container.

    When do kittens start reacting to catnip?

    Usually somewhere between three and six months. Until then, choose toys that move, such as wands, balls and soft mice.

    Are matatabi and valerian safe for cats?

    They are considered safe in normal amounts. Supervise chewing, replace splintered sticks and check with your vet if your cat has a health condition.

    Does catnip stop working as cats get older?

    Some older cats become less interested over time. If your cat used to love catnip, try fresh catnip first, then matatabi or valerian.

    This article is general information and not veterinary advice.

    Happy playing from Amy, Pancake and Marmalade. Shop catnip, valerian and matatabi toys.

    Source: Bol S. et al. (2017), "Responsiveness of cats (Felidae) to silver vine, Tatarian honeysuckle, valerian and catnip", BMC Veterinary Research.

    Written by Amy BerchnerMaker behind Calico & Clover. I sew natural wool cat toys by hand in Wuppertal, tested daily by my two rescue cats, Pancake and Marmalade.